[ANALYSIS] What is Seoul aiming for by prioritizing human rights in North Korea?
发布时间:2024-09-23 11:24:14 作者:玩站小弟 我要评论
People bow to portraits of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in Pyongyang, in this November 2021 photo
。
People bow to portraits of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in Pyongyang, in this November 2021 photo. Yonhap |
Peaceful unity impossible without 'revolutionary change' in Pyongyang first: US experts
By Jung Min-ho
After his decision to replace three key figures in charge of handling inter-Korean relations, President Yoon Suk Yeol called on the unification ministry to fundamentally change the way it operates, saying its unification efforts should be based on the Constitution.
Article 4 of the Constitution says that Korea should "formulate and carry out a policy of peaceful unification based on the principles of freedom and democracy."
What does that mean for the ministry's future role and the prospects of unification?
According to U.S. analysts, it would mean achieving freedom and democracy in North Korea first before pursuing peaceful unification. Without a "revolutionary change" in Pyongyang, unification is impractical to attain or maintain, they said. In other words, if the North regime remains as it has always been ― trampling on the freedom of its citizens as a means of holding onto power ― the government under Yoon is unlikely to prioritize efforts to hasten unification, which would not be sustainable anyway.
Allen Pinkston, an analyst on North Korea and a professor of international relations at Troy University in the U.S. state of Alabama, said he does not see "any progress toward unification" as long as North Korea is under its Workers' Party, which is intolerant of any vision of a unified Korea that does not include its system of governance.
"If the Kim regime and the DPRK (North Korea) party-state were to liberalize, democratize, and protect human rights, this would represent a revolutionary change in thinking and identity," Pinkston said.
"Of course, the other possibility is the South coming under the control of the DPRK. I don't think that is likely at all, so the more likely scenario is eventual revolutionary change in the North, and subsequent unification under the democratic ideals as envisioned by the Yoon administration."
His assessment seems to be in line with Kim Yung-ho, nominee for new unification minister. In the past media columns and interviews, the former human rights ambassador expressed his skepticism of unification under two different political systems, saying it would almost certainly lead to civil war as the ongoing conflict in Yemen and many other such failures have shown.
Kim Yung-ho, nominee for new minister of unification, speaks to reporters while entering the Office of the Inter-Korean Dialogue in Seoul, June 30. Yonhap |
Kim consistently insisted that South Korea should prioritize human rights in its policy toward the North to pressure the regime to change its abhorrent behavior. In comments suggesting regime change, he also called for the end of Kim Jong-un's rule and the "destruction" of North Korea's political system.
Some experts such as Robert Joseph, former U.S. special envoy for nuclear nonproliferation, believe Washington and Seoul should place human rights at the center of their policies on the North, saying that joint international pressure could lead to regime change from within.
It is unclear whether such an upfront, aggressive human rights approach is among the ideas Kim is considering as new minister. What is rather obvious is that the ministry will likely toughen its hardline stance, as he told reporters last week that freedom, human rights and rule of law are among the uncompromising values.
Sean King, senior vice president at Park Strategies, a New York-based advisory firm, said it is wrong to believe that the promotion of human rights conflicts with the goal of unification in the long run.
"Caring and knowing about North Koreans' suffering and plight will only make any eventual Korean reunification more durable and resilient," King said. "Assuming Korea reunited one day under the Seoul system, it should mean something to Koreans in the North that South Koreans cared about their plight while they were separated."
相关文章
Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data
(Getty Images)Births to those not married accounted for nearly 5 percent of all births last year, se2024-09-23- 可快速打印8米长建筑模型的3D打印机亮相电博会 71款创新性产品凭独特设计赢好评昨日,2017电博会如火如荼地进行中,展会将于今日落下帷幕。上周末,很多市民将逛电博会提上日程,电博会成为一家老小周末休2024-09-23
- 一线观察丨患者就医最看重什么?槽点依然集中在……_南方+_南方plus选择医院就医,对于医疗技术、医护服务、医院环境,患者最看重哪方面呢?近日,记者走访广州三甲公立医院,随机采访了数位不同年龄段的就医2024-09-23
- 封海近四个月,黄海今日开渔。休渔的近四个月时间里,养殖水产、冻品齐上阵,也没欠了市民的口福,尤其8月1日东海部分开海后,“梭子蟹”大军北上,迅速占领岛城市场。从8月开始,海鲜市2024-09-23
Kamala Harris’ ridiculous problem with the political press.
Last Thursday, standing on the tarmac in Michigan in front of Air Force Two, Kamala Harris took some2024-09-23- 我市将围绕生态文化旅游、康养培育建立一批现代服务业聚集区消费是拉动国民经济增长的“三驾马车”之一。一季度,我市服务业增加值实现75.39亿元,增加值增速同比增长0.6%,全省排名第2位,高于全省增速平2024-09-23
最新评论